24 Aug, 2025

Trouble for Shein and Temu in South Africa presents a clear winner

Trouble for Shein and Temu in South Africa presents a clear winner

FNB Wealth and Investments’ Chantal Marx believes that local retailers like Mr Price present a strong investment opportunity as many South Africans grow tired of Shein and Temu.

Speaking to Business Day TV, Marx said that several retailers in South Africa offer good value. This includes Truworths, Pepkor and Shoprite—but Marx is putting her money behind Mr Price. 

Marx thinks the group is a clear winner in the discretionary retail space. She also noted that a Shein and Temu fatigue is kicking in across South Africa, which Mr Price can benefit from. 

Shein and Temu offer quick fashion imports at often too-good-to-be-true price points. However, consumers are often left disappointed at the quality of items received—if they receive them at all.

While this has served markets looking for cheaper items, recent import changes have severely undercut this, meaning consumers are now starting to pay higher prices for the same questionable result.

 

Following the recent release a disappointing trading statement, Marx believes there is a good opportunity to buy Mr Price, which operates in a similar low-cost fast-fashion segment.

The retailer’s latest trading statement for the first quarter from 30 March 2025 to 28 June 2025 showed that the group’s retail sales increased by 6.3% to R9 billion, with 10 basis points of market share growth. 

April (11.3%) and May (11.9%) both saw strong sales growth over the period, with the group benefiting from the timing shift of the Easter holidays into April.

May benefited from a timely winter season against a weak base of negative sales growth as many cut back spending ahead of the 2024 national election. 

However, in June 2025, the group saw its retail sales decline by 5.1% against a firm base of +12.7%. 

Mt Price said that the group’s strong performance in June 2024 was mainly due to the late onset of winter, which created pent-up demand in the first two weeks of the month. 

It expected softer sales in the month, but the impact of the shift in school holidays from the last two weeks in July was greater than expected. 

 

Higher markdown activity was required from Mr Price, a trend observed by most in the industry.

Despite the challenging month, Marx is optimistic about the group’s performance. 

“One bad month does not a trend make. They had a very poor June, but they expect July (+12.9%) to be a lot stronger,” said Marx. 

“I think momentum has returned from a retail sales perspective and Mr Price is also gaining market share.”  

 

 

Group’s optimism

FNB Wealth and Investments’ Chantal Marx

 

Mr Price is also optimistic about its future, with the group’s store footprint growing to 3,061 stores over the quarter. 

The group has been rapidly expanding its store base since mid-2021, when it had 1,400 outlets. The growth was fuelled by strategic acquistions and further investment in existing brands. 

It purchased Yuppiechef, Power Fashion and Studio 88 in the period while expanding into standalone Mr Price Kids and Mr Price Baby stores. 

 

This came despite a challenging operating environment, with the local business conditions remaining disruptive, especially in 2024 and 2025. 

The group has flagged the potential disruption from proposed trade tariffs of over 30% from the US, which has clouded the growth trajectory moving forward.

“The volatility of the domestic economic landscape makes the outlook for the remainder of the financial year likely to be characterised by inconsistent consumer trends,” it said.

“The short-term relief measures of low inflation and interest rates will intersect with an increasingly firm H2 base, as well as rising food and fuel prices, which will impact disposable income.” 

Nevertheless, the group remains optimistic that it can continue to achieve margin-accretive market share gains. Annual space growth is anticipated to increase on a weighted average basis by roughly 4%.

Mr Price said it will primarily focuses on driving consistent performance in the Apparel and Telecoms segments. Strategic improvements in the homeware segment are showing positive progress. 

It said it remains confident it can achieve its medium-term targets and deliver sustainable long-term returns.

 

 

Revenue

 

Earnings

 

 

 

Issued on BusinessTech by Luke Fraser | https://businesstech.co.za/news/business-opinion/833279/trouble-for-shein-and-temu-in-south-africa-presents-a-clear-winner/